Vest CPA
← All postsEquity compSep 11, 20268 min readDrew Duskin, CPA

The ISO and AMT trap: how to exercise without a surprise tax bill

Why we wrote this

We wrote this because people search for it, usually right after a bad April, and we'd like them to find us before that one. In Drew's experience, planning for AMT before an ISO exercise is one of the things generalist CPAs most often miss. Here's how it works, with the 2026 numbers.

How do you exercise ISOs without a surprise tax bill?

You exercise ISOs without a surprise tax bill by knowing your AMT number before you exercise, not after. In practice:

  • Find your AMT room. That's how much spread you can take this year before AMT kicks in.
  • Size the exercise. Stay inside that room, or go over it on purpose because you've decided it's worth it.
  • Pay for it during the year. If you go over, make estimated payments so April isn't a shock.
  • Track the credit. AMT paid on ISOs usually comes back later as a credit. Don't lose it.
  • Repeat next year. Multi-year planning is where most of the savings live.

Drew puts it simply: ISOs are the one exercise decision he's usually involved in, because you can plan the AMT in advance. Every other piece of this article explains one of those five steps.

Why does exercising ISOs trigger AMT?

ISO exercise plan

Same options. Less AMT. It’s all in the timing.

With a plan~$35,700Total. Split the exercise over two years.
~$45,000
~$35,700
Exercise all in one yearSplit over two years
Illustration only. Round numbers. Not tax advice.Assumes a single filer, $200,000 salary, 10,000 ISOs, $5 strike, $25 fair market value, 2026 rules. About $31,000 of spread fits in a year with no AMT.

ISOs get special treatment for regular tax. According to IRS Publication 525, there's no regular tax when they're granted or when you exercise them. The AMT doesn't follow that rule.

When you exercise and keep the shares past year-end, the bargain element (fair market value at exercise minus your strike price) is added to your income for AMT. It's reported on Form 6251, and it raises your AMT basis in the shares by the same amount. If you sell the shares in the same calendar year you exercised, there's no AMT adjustment at all.

AMT is a parallel calculation. You figure your tentative minimum tax alongside your regular tax, and if the tentative minimum tax is higher, you pay the difference as AMT.

Your strike price can't be below the stock's fair market value on the grant date, which is why private companies get a 409A valuation. As the company grows, the gap between your strike and the current value widens. That gap is what AMT taxes.

Your employer sends Form 3921 for each ISO exercise by January 31 of the following year. By then the year is over and the planning window is closed.

The 2026 AMT numbers

These come from IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32 and apply to 2026:

  • Exemption: $90,100 single, $140,200 married filing jointly, $70,100 married filing separately.
  • Phaseout starts: $500,000 single, $1,000,000 joint, $500,000 married filing separately.
  • Phaseout speed: you lose 50 cents of exemption for every dollar over the threshold. Before 2026 it was 25 cents.
  • Exemption fully gone: $680,200 single, $1,280,400 joint.
  • Rates: 26%, then 28% on AMT taxable income above $244,500 ($122,250 married filing separately).
  • ISO limit: $100,000 of stock first exercisable per year, valued at grant.
  • Holding periods for the best treatment: more than 2 years from grant and more than 1 year from exercise.
  • Form 3921: from your employer by January 31.

The 2026 change matters more than most people realize. The phaseout now starts lower than it did in 2025, and the exemption disappears twice as fast. In our experience, most people with ISOs haven't heard about it yet.

For a two-income tech household, $1,000,000 sounds far away. A large exercise on top of two salaries can close that gap quickly. And inside the phaseout range, each extra dollar of spread is taxed at the AMT rate and also shrinks your exemption, so the real rate on that dollar runs well above 28%.

An illustrative example, with round numbers

Here's a simple example. It's an illustration, not a projection, and it leaves out details a real projection would include.

Say a single filer has $200,000 of salary and no other income. They hold ISOs on 10,000 shares with a $5 strike, and the stock is now worth $25 a share. They exercise all 10,000 in 2026 and hold the shares.

  • Cash to exercise: 10,000 x $5 = $50,000.
  • Bargain element: 10,000 x $20 = $200,000. No regular tax on it.
  • AMT income: about $400,000. That's under $500,000, so the full $90,100 exemption applies.
  • AMT taxable income: about $309,900.
  • Tentative minimum tax: 26% of $309,900, plus another 2% on the $65,400 above $244,500. About $81,900.
  • Regular tax on the $200,000 salary: about $36,700, using the 2026 standard deduction of $16,100 and 2026 brackets published by the IRS.
  • AMT owed: about $45,000, due in April 2027, on shares they may not be able to sell.

Now say the same person splits it: 5,000 shares in 2026 and 5,000 in 2027, with the same salary and the same share price.

  • Spread each year: $100,000.
  • AMT income each year: about $300,000. AMT taxable income: $209,900.
  • Tentative minimum tax each year: about $54,600.
  • AMT owed each year: about $17,800. Across both years, about $35,700.

Splitting it cuts the AMT paid up front by about $9,500 here, and the cash needed to exercise drops to $25,000 a year. In this example, about $31,000 of spread fits in a year with no AMT at all. That number moves with your income, deductions and share price, which is why we project it every year.

There's a tradeoff. If the share price keeps climbing, next year's spread is bigger, and waiting also pushes back the one-year holding clock on those shares. That's a judgment call we make with you, not a formula.

Do you get the AMT back?

Often, yes, over time. AMT caused by deferral items, like the ISO adjustment, creates a minimum tax credit. Per the instructions for Form 8801, you carry it forward and use it in later years to the extent your regular tax is higher than your tentative minimum tax. The statute doesn't set an expiration date.

Two catches. The credit can come back slowly in years when your regular tax is only a little above your tentative minimum tax. And it doesn't help your cash in the April you owe. The year you sell the shares can speed things up, because your higher AMT basis means less AMT gain.

Keep track of it every year, especially if you change who prepares your return.

Qualifying vs disqualifying dispositions: when should you sell?

A qualifying disposition means selling more than 2 years after the grant date and more than 1 year after you exercised. Meet both, and the whole gain over your strike price is capital gain, under Section 422 of the tax code.

A disqualifying disposition means selling before either date. The gain is ordinary income up to the spread at exercise. Anything above that is capital gain. If you sell at a loss, it's a capital loss, with no ordinary income.

Remember that a same-year sale means no AMT adjustment. If you exercise shares you're able to sell early in the year and the price drops, a sale before December 31 can take the AMT adjustment off the table. You trade it for ordinary income on the spread, limited to your actual gain. That only works if you exercise early enough to have the option.

Two more things to watch when you sell:

  • The cost basis trap. For options granted on or after January 1, 2014, the basis on your Form 1099-B won't include income you already reported. On a disqualifying disposition, if you don't correct it on Form 8949, that income gets taxed twice: once as wages and again as capital gain.
  • Washington's capital gains tax. A qualifying sale produces long-term capital gain, which can count toward Washington's capital gains tax: 7%, plus 2.9% on Washington capital gains over $1 million, above an annual standard deduction.

What is the $100,000 ISO limit?

If the stock for ISOs that first become exercisable in one calendar year is worth more than $100,000, valued at the grant date, the excess is treated as nonqualified stock options (NSOs). Options count in the order they were granted.

Here's a simple example. Say your grant covers stock worth $600,000 at the grant date, vesting evenly over four years. That's $150,000 becoming exercisable each year, so $100,000 a year can be ISOs and $50,000 a year is treated as NSOs. With NSOs, the spread is generally taxed as ordinary income when you exercise, so those options need their own plan.

If you're offered early exercise, be careful. An 83(b) election on early-exercised ISOs only matters for AMT. It doesn't lock in capital gains treatment, and the holding period for the regular tax rules generally starts at vesting. Our 83(b) article covers how the election works.

The most common mistake we see

Exercise first, ask later. Someone exercises a big block, holds the shares, and learns about AMT when the return gets prepared. Drew's estimate of what that costs: four to five figures of tax, usually as a surprise bill in April that nobody planned for.

We see the same pattern with other equity, too. One employee sold a large block of RSU shares at the end of the year and tripped Washington's capital gains tax. By the time they came to us, it was too late for loss harvesting, a donor-advised fund or anything else. Ideally they would have kept the sale under the threshold. Different tax, same lesson: the planning has to happen before the transaction, not after.

If you do go over, pay estimated tax. According to the tax code's safe harbor rules, you avoid an underpayment penalty if your withholding and timely estimates cover the lesser of 90% of this year's tax or 100% of last year's. That becomes 110% of last year's tax if your prior-year AGI was over $150,000.

Thinking about exercising? Run the numbers with us first

Drew runs AMT projections for clients on our tax planning subscription, and the projection is part of it. We work with tech employees with equity in Seattle and Bellevue, and with clients in the Bay Area and Austin. If you're holding ISOs and thinking about exercising this year or next, apply here. You can also see how we work and what it costs.

Not ready yet? Grab the Equity Comp Tax Guide. It covers RSUs, ISOs, AMT, the $100,000 limit and ESPP cost basis in one place.

*This article is general information, not tax advice for your situation. Rules change, and the details matter. Talk to a CPA before you act.*

Related serviceEquity Compensation Tax Planning→
Sources (12)
  1. IRS Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income: https://www.irs.gov/publications/p525
  2. IRS Topic 427, Stock Options: https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc427
  3. Cornell Legal Information Institute, 26 U.S.C. 422 (incentive stock options): https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/422
  4. IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32 (2026 inflation adjustments): https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-25-32.pdf
  5. Cornell Legal Information Institute, 26 U.S.C. 55 (AMT): https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/55
  6. IRS Instructions for Form 8801 (2025): https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/i8801.pdf
  7. Cornell Legal Information Institute, 26 U.S.C. 53 (minimum tax credit): https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/53
  8. Cornell Legal Information Institute, 26 U.S.C. 6654 (estimated tax safe harbor): https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/6654
  9. Treas. Reg. 1.409A-1 (option strike price and fair market value): https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.409A-1
  10. Morrison & Foerster, early exercise of ISOs (Jan 16, 2026): https://www.mofo.com/pdf/resources/insights/260116-early-exercise-of-isos-why-it-doesn-t-work
  11. RCW 82.87.040, Washington capital gains tax rates: https://app.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=82.87.040
  12. Washington Department of Revenue, capital gains tax: https://dor.wa.gov/taxes-rates/other-taxes/capital-gains-tax

This article is general information, not tax advice for your situation. Rules change, and the details matter. Talk to a CPA before you act.

Step 01 · Apply

Ready when you are.

Apply in about 5 minutes. We reply by email, and if it looks like a fit, we book a free 15-minute call.