When should you make an S election if you aren't raising money?
Why we wrote this
We wrote this because founders search for "what profit do I need for an S corp" and find a confident number with nothing behind it. We'd like you to find us instead, and we'd like to earn that by being straight with you. So here's the real reasoning, the deadline, and the part most people skip: reasonable compensation.
When should you make an S election if you aren't raising money?
You should make an S election when the tax you save on profit outweighs what it costs to run payroll and file the extra return, and when nothing on your roadmap needs a C corp. That's the whole test. It depends on your numbers, not on a rule of thumb.
Here's the setup it applies to. You run a business that makes money. Maybe it's a consulting practice, an agency, or a product with paying customers. You don't plan to sell equity to investors. You want profit to come to you. For that kind of founder, an LLC or an S corp usually fits better than a C corp. (If you're still choosing your entity, start with LLC vs S corp vs C corp.)
According to the IRS instructions for Form 2553, an LLC that's eligible to be treated as a corporation can make the S election by filing Form 2553 on time, without a separate Form 8832. The election doesn't change your legal entity. It changes how the business is taxed.
How does an S election save tax?
An S election saves tax by changing how your profit is hit by self-employment tax. In most cases, a pass-through owner without an S election pays self-employment tax on their share of the profit. With an S election, you become an employee of your own company. You pay payroll tax on a reasonable salary, and the rest of the profit can come out as distributions without self-employment tax.
Here's a simple example. The numbers are made up to show the idea, not to suggest a cutoff. Say a founder's business makes $200,000 of profit, and a reasonable salary for the work they do is $120,000.
- Without an S election: in most cases, self-employment tax applies to the founder's share of the full $200,000.
- With an S election: payroll tax applies to the $120,000 salary. The other $80,000 can come out as distributions without self-employment tax.
Now change one input. Say a reasonable salary for that same founder is really $190,000. Only $10,000 escapes payroll tax, and the cost of running payroll and filing an S corp return (Form 1120-S) may eat most or all of that. Same profit, very different answer. That's why the salary question matters more than the profit number.
Why won't we give you a profit number?
We won't give you a profit number because there isn't a reliable one. The IRS doesn't publish a break-even point for S elections. The numbers you'll see online come from vendor and small-firm blogs, not from the IRS or any source we'd stand behind. Your answer depends on:
- what a reasonable salary is for your role
- how much profit is left after that salary
- what payroll, the extra return and bookkeeping cost you
- how your state treats S corps (some states don't fully follow S status)
- what you plan to do with the company in the next few years
We'd rather model your actual numbers than hand you a number that fits someone else's business. That's part of what we do in our startup tax returns work.
What counts as reasonable compensation?
Reasonable compensation is the salary an S corp has to pay a shareholder who works in the business before taking non-wage distributions. According to the IRS, the IRS can reclassify distributions as wages subject to employment tax if the salary is too low.
Courts look at factors like these:
- your training and experience
- your duties
- how much time you spend on the business
- what comparable businesses pay for similar work
- the company's dividend history
- any compensation agreements
The temptation is obvious. Pay yourself a tiny salary and take everything else as distributions. Don't. It's the first thing that makes an S election look better on paper than it is in real life. When we set up an S corp with a founder, we work out a salary we can defend before we run any savings math. Payroll runs through Gusto when we help with it, and our startup accounting team keeps the salary and distributions straight in the books.
When does an S election stop making sense?
An S election stops making sense when the savings shrink or the restrictions start to block your plans. Watch for these:
- Profit is close to a reasonable salary. There's little left to take as distributions.
- The costs add up. Payroll, a separate return and cleaner books all cost money.
- Your state adds cost. Some states don't fully follow S status.
- You might raise. S corps can't issue preferred stock, so a typical VC round can't happen in one.
- You want owners an S corp can't have. According to the IRS, an S corp can have no more than 100 shareholders and only one class of stock. Shareholders must be individuals, certain trusts or estates, so no partnerships, corporations or nonresident aliens.
- You care about QSBS. S corp stock never qualifies for the QSBS exclusion. QSBS needs stock in a domestic C corp.
If any of these are on your radar for the next few years, talk to us before you elect.
What's the deadline for an S election?
The deadline for an S election is no more than 2 months and 15 days after the start of the tax year you want it to take effect. You can also file it any time during the year before. For a calendar-year company, that means March 15.
According to the IRS instructions for Form 2553, all shareholders have to consent. The form is mailed or faxed to the IRS service center listed in the instructions. We haven't found an IRS e-file or online option for Form 2553, so plan for mail or fax.
Key dates for an S election
- March 15: deadline for a calendar-year company to elect S status for that year
- Monday, March 15, 2027: the deadline for elections that start in 2027
- 2 months and 15 days: the window after a new company's first tax year starts. In the IRS's own example, a new corporation whose first tax year starts January 7 has until March 21.
- Any time in the prior year: you can file early for next year
- 3 years and 75 days: the general window for late election relief (see below)
What if you missed the S election deadline?
If you missed the deadline, you may still be able to fix it. Under Rev. Proc. 2013-30, relief is generally available when:
- the late filing had reasonable cause
- the corporation acted diligently to fix it once someone noticed
- the election is filed within 3 years and 75 days of the date you wanted it to take effect
- the shareholders reported their taxes consistently with S status
You write "FILED PURSUANT TO REV. PROC. 2013-30" at the top of the form. Past 3 years and 75 days, there's a narrower path, and if that doesn't fit, the next step is a private letter ruling, which comes with an IRS user fee. Relief exists, but it's paperwork you don't want. Calendar the deadline.
What's the most common mistake we see?
The most common mistake is making the election on autopilot. A friend says an S corp saves tax, so the founder elects without asking where the company is headed. Wrong entity for the founder's goals is one of the problems we see most.
Two versions of this come up again and again:
- An S corp, or a partnership, when the founder really needs a C corp. They later want outside funding, and the setup can't take it. Now they're restructuring instead of raising.
- A pass-through entity that issues equity to employees. In an LLC taxed as a partnership, that employee becomes a partner, with a K-1 instead of a W-2. Drew has seen these turn into multiple five-figure cleanup projects between tax and legal. If equity for your team is part of the plan, a pass-through entity is a poor fit.
Neither one is a disaster on day one. Both are expensive to unwind later. The fix is a short conversation before you file, not after.
Want help deciding if an S election fits? Let's run your numbers
We're not going to tell you an S election is always smart or always a waste. We'll look at your profit, what a defensible salary is, what it all costs, and where the business is headed, and then tell you what we'd do.
Our team, led by Drew, works with founders in Seattle and Bellevue, the Bay Area, Austin and anywhere else in the US. If you're early and bootstrapping, our Founder Tax Blueprint gives you a plan and the dates to track. If you're ready for ongoing tax and accounting help, apply to work with us, and see how we work and what it costs. For the full list of setup steps, grab the 83(b) and QSBS Founder Checklist.
*This article is general information, not tax advice for your situation. Rules change, and the details matter. Talk to a CPA before you act.*
Related serviceStartup Formation→Sources (4)
- IRS, S corporation compensation and medical insurance issues: https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/s-corporation-compensation-and-medical-insurance-issues
- IRS, S corporations: https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/s-corporations
- IRS, Instructions for Form 2553: https://www.irs.gov/instructions/i2553
- Not linked in the body but used for facts: Cornell Law School, 26 U.S.C. 1202 (QSBS needs a domestic C corp): https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/1202 . IRS, "Paying yourself" (partners and W-2s): https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/paying-yourself
This article is general information, not tax advice for your situation. Rules change, and the details matter. Talk to a CPA before you act.